Supreme Court of New South Wales

Court of Appeal practice

Guidance on how the Court expects legal practitioners will conduct an appeal

E: courtofappeal@justice.nsw.gov.au

P: 1300 679 272


Coming up in the Court of Appeal

CW v Director of Public Prosecutions

2026/00252006

Monday, 16 November 2026

ADMIN LAW (judicial review) – on 24 November 2025, following a trial before the trial judge and a jury, CW was found guilty of three counts of sexual intercourse with a child under 10 years of age and one count of intentionally sexually touching a child under 10 years of age – CW had previously been convicted of a charge of sexually touching another person without consent in 2019 – CW had also pleaded guilty to several charges of sexual offending in April 2024, but was granted leave to withdraw those pleas on 20 December 2024 – upon discharging the jury after the return of their verdict, the trial judge requested that the jury remain “for the commencement of the sentence proceedings” and to hear “some of the information which will come from the Crown” – the Crown proceeded to reveal, amongst other things, CW’s conviction in 2019 and his withdrawn guilty pleas to the discharged jury – the trial judge explained that his Honour wished for the discharged jury to hear this information because several jurors “appeared to be quite stressed and anxious throughout the trial” – by summons filed 18 June 2026, CW commenced proceedings seeking declaratory relief and an order in the nature of prohibition restraining the trial judge from hearing CW’s sentencing proceedings – CW asserts that the trial judge’s remarks to the discharged jury give rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias that his Honour might not bring an impartial and unprejudiced mind to the sentencing of CW.

Counsel

  • Appellant: G Reynolds SC, G D Wendler
  • Respondent: D Kell SC, C Winnett
CharterLaw Legal Pty Limited v Diane Maloney

2026/00371032

Tuesday, 17 November 2026

ADMIN LAW (judicial review) – the applicant (CharterLaw) is a law firm who previously acted for the first respondent (Ms Maloney) – following Ms Maloney’s termination of its legal services, CharterLaw applied for a costs assessment of the unpaid costs and disbursements said to be owing by Ms Maloney – on 17 February 2026, the costs assessor issued cost certificates (the Certificates) assessing the costs payable by Ms Maloney to CharterLaw at $121,748.58 – on 23 February 2026, CharterLaw filed the Certificates in the District Court of New South Wales (District Court), whereupon they took effect as a judgment of the Court by virtue of s 70(5) of the Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW) (February judgment) – on 15 June 2026, Ms Maloney filed a notice of motion seeking (amongst other things) to set aside the February judgment under r 36.15 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (UCPR) – Ms Maloney contended that, in circumstances where CharterLaw had provided its legal services to multiple entities associated with Ms Maloney, rather than to her exclusively, she was not the proper costs respondent in respect of the amount payable under the Certificates – the District Court found that “a substantial part of the legal services were provided to corporate entities, separate and distinct” from Ms Maloney – the District Court further found that the costs assessor did not make a formal finding that Ms Maloney was the proper costs respondent – the District Court accordingly set aside the February judgment under r 36.15(1) of the UCPR – whether the District Court’s decision in setting aside the February judgment is vitiated by jurisdictional error or error on the face of the record.

Submissions

  1. Applicant's submissions
  2. Respondent's submissions

Counsel

  • Appellant: N Simpson
  • Respondent: N Franco
Romulus Remus Group Pty Ltd v The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy

2026/00185997

Wednesday, 18 November 2026

PROCEDURE – the applicants seek leave to appeal from orders made by McGrath J declaring that the proceedings are those to which ss 13(2) and 13(3) of the Vexatious Proceedings Act 2008 (NSW) or, alternatively, that the proceedings should be stayed until unquantified costs orders have been made. The underlying dispute relates to the administration of a property in Point Piper upon the bankruptcies of two of the owners. The current proceedings concern an application by the respondent for orders that the proceedings be dismissed or stayed, or alternatively that the statement of claim be struck out. The applicant alleges that the primary judge erred in his Honour’s application of r 12.4 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) and in finding that s 13 of the Vexatious Proceedings Act had automatic operation in circumstances where the person instituting the proceedings is acting in concert with a person who has been declared a vexatious litigant. The applicant further alleges that the primary judge erred in concluding that the proceedings should be stayed pending the payment of costs.

Decision under appeal

Romulus Remus Group Pty Limited v The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2026] NSWSC 317

Counsel

  • Appellant: TBC
  • Respondent: B A Ng
The Eddie Arnott Corporation Pty Ltd v Sydney Metro

2025/00393673

Thursday, 19 November 2026

LAND & ENVIRONMENT – on 21 February 2023, the Eddie Arnott Corporation Pty Ltd (the first appellant) brought proceedings pursuant to s 66 of the Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act 1991 (NSW) objecting to the amount of compensation offered by Sydney Metro (the respondent) for the compulsory acquisition of its freehold interest in land comprising Lot 7 in Strata Plan 65054 (the acquired land) – the acquired land was in the lower ground level of what was known as the Hunter Connection, and had been used for the purpose of a dental practice by Dr Arnaout (the second appellant) – the appellants approached the Land and Environment Court for a determination of compensation, and put in issue whether another legal person, namely the second appellant, had an interest in land by reason of the unregistered 2022 lease – the appellants claimed compensation in the amount of $7,473,977.79 – the primary judge held that the appellants had no entitlement to compensation for special value, or for relocation costs or stamp duty costs as loss attributable to disturbance – the primary judge further held that the “Owner Occupier Financial Structure” upon which the second appellant relied for the purpose of his separate claim was, as Sydney Metro submitted, primarily a personal relationship, rather than one that related to property – the primary judge determined that the appellant was entitled to a total compensation in the amount of $1,102,000.00 – whether the primary judge erred in excluding critical evidence, including the second appellant’s expert valuation report and affidavits, on procedural grounds, resulting in a denial of natural justice and failure to afford the appellants a fair hearing – whether the appellants suffered manifest unfairness and fundamental procedural irregularity, being denied a reasonable opportunity to present their case, including through late procedural rulings and the refusal of reasonable extensions for compliance with Notices to Produce – whether the primary judge failed to consider and give weight to the extensive evidence in support of the appellants' claims compiled in Evidence Book volumes – whether the primary judge relied solely on the respondent's valuation evidence, in the absence of competing evidence, leading to the manifest under-compensation of both freehold and leasehold interests, contrary to the Land Acquisition (Just Terms Compensation) Act.

Decision under appeal

The Eddie Arnott Corporation Pty Ltd v Sydney Metro (No 4) [2025] NSWLEC 103

Counsel

  • Appellant: self
  • Respondent J Steele SC, A Hemmings
Martinus Rail Pty Ltd v Qube RE Services (No.2) Pty Ltd in its capacity as trustee of the MooreBank Industrial Terminals Assets Trust

2026/00372033

Thursday, 19 November 2026

PROCEDURE – the applicant seeks leave to appeal from orders made by Peden J enforcing certain arbitral awards under the Commercial Arbitration Act 2010 (NSW). The proceedings arise from an application by the respondent to enforce three “partial” arbitral awards, which the applicant challenged on public policy grounds. Following the orders made by Peden J, the applicant sought to stay those orders pending the determination of leave to appeal, which Price AJA granted on the condition that the applicant pay into court the amount owed under the arbitral awards. The applicant alleges that the primary judge erred in her Honour’s interpretation of cl 42 of the parties’ arbitral agreement and its interaction with s 35 of the Commercial Arbitration Act.

Decision under appeal

Qube Re Services (No 2) Pty Limited v Martinus Rail Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 717

Counsel

  • Appellant: F Corsaro, D Ratnam
  • Respondent: T Breakspear SC
Historical and factual information about Australia's first intermediate appellate court
Summaries of significant cases that relate to sections of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW)
Delegations made pursuant to s 13 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Visit the Supreme Court fees page
Information on how to commence an appeal and more
Frequently cited legislation and sources of jurisdiction
Practice Note SC CA 1 - For the preparation and conduct of proceedings
Published pursuant to clause 27 of Practice Note SC CA 1

List of Authorities

Parties to hearings before the Court of Appeal (excluding leave only hearings) are required, in accordance with paragraphs 34 to 40 of Practice Note SC CA 1  (PDF, 263.5 KB)to lodge list(s) of authorities no later than 48 hours before commencement of the hearing.

A template list of authorities, which includes further instructions, is available here (DOCX, 36.5 KB).

Decisions of Interest

The Decisions of Interest Bulletin is compiled once per fortnight.  It contains summaries of recent decisions of the New South Wales Court of Appeal, other Australian intermediate appellate courts, Asia Pacific appellate courts and other international appellate courts, with the aim of collecting and promoting awareness and accessibility of particularly significant recent decisions.


Judges of the Court of Appeal

​Chie​f ​​J​ustice of ​​NSW​​​​​​A​​​​ssociat​​eEmailTelephone
The Hon. A S Bell​​Edwina ChapmanAssociate to the Chief Justice(02) 9230 8218
P​​resident of the Court of AppealAssociateEmailTelephone
The Hon. Justice Julie WardGiorgina KotevskiAssociate to President Ward(02) 9230 8205
Judges of AppealAssociateEmailTelephone
The Hon. Justice Mark LeemingNazim RahmanAssociate to Justice Leeming​​​(02) 9230 8790
​​The Hon. Justice Anthony Payne​Alexandra McDonald​Associate to Justice Payne(02) 9230 8056​
​The Hon. Justice Anna Mitchelmore​Megwyn Mosenthal​Chambers of Justice Mitchelmore​(02) 9230 8095
​The Hon. Justice Jeremy Kirk​Henry Palmerlee​Chambers of Justice Kirk(02) 9230 8053​
​The Hon. Justice Christine Adamson​Lynn-Maree Nielsen​Associate to Justice Adamson​(02) 9230 8201
​The Hon. Justice Kristina Stern​Isabel Gahan​Chambers of Justice Stern​(02) 9230 8765
The Hon. Justice Richard McHughAya AdelChambers of Justice McHugh(02) 9230 8752
The Hon. Justice Michael BallMaria KourtisAssociate to Justice Ball(02) 9230 8633
The Hon. Justice Stephen FreeJane GrayAssociate  to Justice Free(02) 9230 8223

Last updated: